Vietnam denies use of stun gun to break protest
The Associated Press8/29/2008
Pdf Email cho bạn bè In Ra Tăng Cỡ Chữ Giảm Cỡ Chữ Cỡ Chữ Ban Đầu

HANOI, Vietnam, Fri Aug 29, 9:58 AM ET - Vietnamese authorities denied Friday that they had used force or stun guns to break up a demonstration by Catholics who are demanding the return of land the Communist government took more than four decades ago.

Responding to accusations from protesters, including one who was bleeding, Hanoi's police chief told reporters Friday that officers had broken up the demonstration of about 300 people peacefully.

"Like police in other countries, we never use any kind of tools to beat unarmed people," Hanoi police Chief Nguyen Duc Nhanh told a news conference. "We just talked to them and the crowd dispersed."

Six people, including two priests, told The Associated Press that police had beaten and shocked church members who had gathered Thursday outside a police station to pray for the release of parishioners who were arrested earlier in the day.

Members of Thai Ha Church in Hanoi have been holding round-the-clock prayer vigils for nearly two weeks to demand the return of land next to their church that the government took in the early 1960s.

On Aug. 15, the day the vigils began, church members knocked down a section of a fence surrounding the property and placed several statues of the Virgin Mary inside.

Police say they arrested three people for damaging the fence. Church members, however, have said four were arrested in the fence incident and another seven following Thursday's demonstration.

One of the priests, Nguyen Ngoc Nam Phong, said Friday that police were lying about their actions.

"I was there and I saw them using stun guns to give electrical shocks to our church members," Phong said in an interview. "I could see the guns flare. They also beat people. Their denial once again shows that they never respect the truth."

Church leaders filed a complaint Friday protesting the conduct of police.

The Associated Press spoke to a parishioner shortly after the clash who had sought refuge inside the church, about 300 yards (meters) from the police station.

"They beat me on my face and used a stun gun to shock my daughter," said Nguyen Thi Phuc, who had blood on her face and shirt.

Hanoi authorities called the news conference Friday to address the land dispute and the charges of police violence.

Vu Hong Khanh, vice chairman of the Hanoi People's Committee, said the church members had no legal basis to demand the return of the land.

"If they need more land for their religious practice they have to apply to authorities to be granted land in accordance with the law," Khanh said.

Parishioners are seeking a 172,000 square foot (16,000 square meter) parcel next to their church. The lot is now occupied by a state-owned textile company.

Although religious freedom has been growing in Vietnam recently, the state closely monitors religious organizations and only recognizes a half-dozen officially sanctioned faiths, including Catholicism.

Catholicism is Vietnam's second-largest faith — after Buddhism — with more than 6 million adherents.

In the years after Vietnam's Communist government took power in 1954, all private land was taken over by the government.

Although demonstrations of any kind are rare in Vietnam, church members have been asserting themselves more boldly in recent months.

Earlier this year, Catholic leaders organized prayer vigils at a parcel of land near Hanoi's main cathedral demanding the return of that site, which once housed the Vatican's embassy in Vietnam.

See Also

8/29/2008
Grootste protest van katholieken in Vietnam sinds 1975 (Tiếng Hòa Lan)
RKnieuws.net
8/29/2008
Vietnamese Catholics Say Police Uses Excessive Force to Break up Peaceful Protest
Associated Press
8/29/2008
Catholics rally at Vietnam police station, three detained
AFP
12/1/2008
Veglie di preghiera a Ho Chi Minh City per i parrocchiani di Thai Ha
Asia-News
12/1/2008
Prayer vigil in Ho Chi Minh City for parishioners of Thai Ha
Asia-News
9/11/2008
Vescovi a Thai Ha per portare solidarietà, mentre è caccia a chi parla ai media
Asia-News
5/5/2009
La polizia vietnamita ha fatto di tutto, ma invano, per fermare un pellegrinaggio a Thai Ha
Asia-News
4/10/2010
Thai Ha parish held prayer vigil for Poland and its Catholic Church
Emily Nguyen
7/24/2009
Thai Ha Catholics' lawyer offers legal assistance to Tam Toa parish
J.B. An Dang
6/17/2009
Les paroissiens de Thai Ha manifestent dans les rues de Hanoi
Eglises d'Asie
5/9/2009
Video: On continual harassments against the lawyer representing Thai Ha Catholic defendants
VietCatholic Network
5/5/2009
Vietnamese Police try everything, but in vain, the Thai Ha pilgrimage goes ahead
Asia-News
5/1/2009
Thai Ha Catholics' Defender suffers more persecution.
J.B. An Dang
4/27/2009
Le autorità di Hanoi tornano all’attacco dei Redentoristi di Thai Ha
Asia-News
4/27/2009
Hanoi authorities renew their attack against Thai Ha Redemptorists
Asia-News
4/26/2009
The Passion of Thai Ha parish continues – priest summoned
J.B. An Dang
4/25/2009
HANOI, VIETNAM: Nouvel empiètement des autorités municipales sur une propriété de la paroisse de Thai Ha
Eglises d'Asie
3/27/2009
Confermata la condanna contro i fedeli di Thai Ha. Cattolici contro l’ingiustizia
Asia-News
3/26/2009
Thai Ha defendants’ appeal opens tomorrow as their attorney is harassed again and again
Asia-News
3/26/2009
Domani l’appello dei fedeli di Thai Ha, nuove vessazioni contro il loro avvocato
Asia-News